What happened on this file
The truck had a $3,115 repair after a rear-side hit: bed off the frame, three panels repaired. The insurer's formula would have paid about $250. The report documented $7,909. The insurer opened at $2,500 the next day, the rebuttal answered it with the insurer's own comparables, and the claim settled six days later at 60% above that first offer.
What's in it
The appraisal (pages 3 to 14)
Pre-loss value from three independent sources, accident-history comparables measured against their own book values, every listing identified, the exclusion disclosed, and the 17c formula answered before the insurer raises it.
The demand letter (15 to 16)
The state's legal basis and claim-handling rule, a 30-day deadline, and a request for the insurer's own data. Written for the client to sign and send.
The rebuttal (17 to 18)
The reply to the $2,500 offer: the insurer's mileage logic corrected and all six comparable pairings laid out in one table. This is the round that moved the number.
Had an accident that wasn't your fault?
Two minutes with the estimator tells you roughly what your car lost. If it's worth pursuing, the report is a flat $249, and you get a full refund if the number I document comes in under the fee.
Check my claim for freeAttorneys, shops and agents
There's a two-page overview of what your office gets, how the number is built, and what to send with a file. Your firm's first file is free: report, demand letter and every rebuttal until it settles. After that, $249 per file, flat, never a percentage of the recovery. Not sure a file is worth it? Send it and I'll tell you within one business day, free.
Overview for attorneys (PDF, 2 pages) More for attorneys